14 Barrett, “Science and Religion”
Natural Theology
At the beginning of the nineteenth century, William Paley published Natural Theology (1802),the text in which he expounded the theory that natural objects such as humans and animals show evidence of design. Paley presented nature as God’s creation, and thus the study of the natural world as comparable to the study of the Bible, because both provided evidence for the existence of God.
Natural Theology situated nature as an important and reliable source of proof in support of the Biblical theory of creation described in Genesis. It was not until Charles Darwin’s publication of On the Origin of Species in 1859 that the use of nature as evidence shifted from supporting Genesis to supporting evolutionary theory. The publication of Darwin’s Origin acted as the catalyst which ignited the simmering debate between science and natural theology that was to rage across the Victorian period. However, whilst Darwin’s radical text did have a profound effect on religious and scientific thought, many simply responded to his evolutionary theory by adapting Darwin’s findings to fit within a Christian framework. Many people failed to understand how natural selection could work without a divine creator.
1881 Caricature of Darwin’s theory in Punch.[Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons Charles Darwin was not the only scientist to study natural history or to use natural history in support of his theory. Several years earlier, Charles Lyell had used geological findings as evidence of God’s design. His most famous work Principles of Geology, published in three volumes from 1830-1833, suggested that the earth was shaped by slow-moving forces that were still in operation – a theory that would later become known as uniformitarianism. Lyell’s explanation of a steady accumulation of change over long periods of time, evident in the present geological structure of the earth, heavily influenced the young Darwin, who had consulted Lyell’s text during his scientific voyage on-board HMS Beagle.
The Popularisation of Science
Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895) was one of the first professional scientists of the Victorian era. Darwin’s greatest advocate – he was known as ‘Darwin’s Bulldog’ due to his support for the theory of evolution – Huxley coined the term ‘Agnostic’ to describe his own views on theology. As a professional scientist, he insisted upon reason and empirical evidence as the only means of properly knowing this world. Faith meant belief in the speculative and the unobserved, and thus was impossible for a scientist. God and the essential being of things were therefore unknown and unknowable.
Huxley presented an alternative view of science that drew upon evolutionary modes of thought. His famous 1860 debate with The Bishop of Oxford, Samuel Wilberforce, was a key moment that aided the wider acceptance of evolutionary theory.
Exhibiting Knowledge
The Victorians were fascinated by the strange new worlds that science opened up