History
2 The Numbered Treaties
Learning Objectives
- Consider why the Government of Canada set out to negotiate the Numbered Treaties.
- Analyze the effects of the Numbered Treaties on Aboriginal Title in British Columbia.
The first order of business for the Canadian government was twofold: secure land for settlement and the construction of the Canadian Pacific Railway to unite the provinces. The Royal Proclamation made it illegal for individuals or businesses to make agreements with Indigenous communities, and the land was explicitly reserved for all Indigenous Peoples. To do this, the government had to purchase lands and so engaged in the process of negotiating the “Numbered Treaties” (Black, 2014).
The Numbered Treaties remain controversial to this day. The Government of Canada views them as treaties for the legal purchase of land, with modest “reserves” set aside for Indigenous groups (Filice, 2016). Affected groups viewed the treaties as a “right-of-way” or a sharing agreement, or did not understand the language that would have made clear the intent of the Canadian government. Further, some chiefs felt they had no choice but to sign due to diminishing local resources and the rapidly changing ability of communities to be self-sustaining. Lastly, some of the signers may not have had authority to sign the treaties — a recurring theme that will come up again later on when discussing the Crown’s “duty to consult.”
The North-West Resistance of 1885 in Saskatchewan and Alberta, led by Louis Riel, was in part a response to the Numbered Treaties. Food was becoming scarce on the previously abundant prairies, and the development on involuntarily surrendered land left the Métis and Plains peoples (Cree, Siksika, Kainai, Piikani, and Saulteaux) in a difficult position. Louis Riel formed a provisional government, which lasted only a few short months before the rebellion was quashed by the Canadian government.
In British Columbia, there is a notable and important absence of Numbered Treaties across most of the province. The rationale for why the federal government did not pursue these treaties more aggressively in British Columbia is unclear. The provincial government website notes, “When British Columbia joined Canada in 1871, the Province did not recognize Indigenous title so there was no need for treaties” (Province of British Columbia, n.d.-b).[1] However, Guuduniia LaBoucan, writing for Canada’s History magazine, notes that the governor of the colony of British Columbia, James Douglas, attempted to negotiate treaties in 1864 (LaBoucan, 2018). This was categorically rejected by the colonial secretary, who wrote that the British taxpayer would not burden themselves with that purely colonial expense. It appears that the governor, not wishing to impede the movement of settlers into B.C., then simply issued proclamations that the Crown owned all land in B.C. — despite the clear language of the Royal Proclamation.[2] This is further complicated by the fact