Alex Rivera | Logout

Why should I ever use inline code?

Asked 2008-09-25T11:32:51.440
32

I'm a C/C++ developer, and here are a couple of questions that always baffled me.

  • Is there a big difference between "regular" code and inline code?
  • Which is the main difference?
  • Is inline code simply a "form" of macros?
  • What kind of tradeoff must be done when choosing to inline your code?

Thanks

Edit
Report

2 Answers

1

Marking a function inline means that the compiler has the option to include in "in-line" where it is called, if the compiler chooses to do so; by contrast, a macro will always be expanded in-place. An inlined function will have appropriate debug symbols set up to allow a symbolic debugger to track the source where it came from, while debugging macros is confusing. Inline functions need to be valid functions, while macros... well, don't.

Deciding to declare a function inline is largely a space tradeoff -- your program will be larger if the compiler decides to inline it (particularly if it isn't also static, in which case at least one non-inlined copy is required for use by any external objects); indeed, if the function is large, this could result in a drop in performance as less of your code fits in cache. The general performance boost, however, is just that you're getting rid of the overhead of the function call itself; for a small function called as part of an inner loop, that's a tradeoff that makes sense.

If you trust your compiler, mark small functions used in inner loops inline liberally; the compiler will be responsible for Doing The Right Thing in deciding whether or not to inline.

answered 2008-09-25T11:40:04.667
0

inlining is a technique to increase speed. But use a profiler to test this in your situation. I have found (MSVC) that inlining does not always deliver and certainly not in any spectacular way. Runtimes sometimes decreased by a few percent but in slightly different circumstances increased by a few percent.

If the code is running slowly, get out your profiler to find troublespots and work on those.

I have stopped adding inline functions to header files, it increases coupling but gives little in return.

answered 2008-09-25T12:56:46.357

Your Answer