Alex Rivera | Logout

Separate 'debug' and 'release' builds?

Asked 2009-01-07T13:42:03.353
47

I think it's better to release the version of the software which your developers actually tested; I therefore tend to delete the 'debug' target from the project/makefile, so that there's only one version that can be built (and tested, and debugged, and released).

For a similar reason, I don't use 'assertions' (see also Are assertions always bad? ...).

One person there argued that the reason for a 'debug' version is that it's easier to debug: but, I counter-argued that you may eventually want to support and debug whatever it is you released, and so you need to build a release which you can if necessary debug ... this may mean enabling debug symbols, and disabling some optimizations, even in the 'release' build.

Someone else said that "this is such a bad idea"; it's a policy I evolved some years ago, having been burned by:

  • Some developers' testing their debug but not release versions
  • Some developers' writing bugs which show up only in the release version
  • The company's releasing the release version after inadequate testing (is it ever entirely adequate?)
  • Being called on to debug the release version

Since then I've seen more than one other development shop follow this practice (i.e. not have separate debug and release builds).

What's your policy?

Edit
Report

1 Answer

1

We always build both, never even considered not doing so. Enabling debug options increases your code size and slows performance, possibly not an issue with your type of software when testing but what if the customer is running your code plus 5 other apps...

The issues with testing can be sorted out by using automated testing so you're release build can be effortlessly tested when you think you're ready to release. The failure of your developers or company to properly test release builds is not a failure in the idea of release and debug builds but in your developers and or company.

On your last point, I have never been called upon to debug a release build, just to fix it...

answered 2009-01-07T13:50:00.997

Your Answer